Under strict scrutiny, which statement is correct?

Under strict scrutiny, which statement is correct?

• A. Government must prove a compelling government interest and be necessary to achieve it
• B. Government must show a legitimate interest
• C. The law must be the least restrictive means
• D. The government must show the best means to achieve a purpose

Answer: (A)

Strict scrutiny requires the government to show a compelling interest behind the law and that the measure is narrowly tailored to achieve that interest, using the least restrictive means. The statement that includes both of these elements—a compelling interest and being necessary to achieve it—best reflects this standard. The other ideas are off because a legitimate, rational-basis interest is not enough under strict scrutiny; recognizing only the least restrictive means is incomplete without asserting a compelling interest; and saying the government must show the best means is not the accepted standard.

Strict scrutiny requires the government to show a compelling interest behind the law and that the measure is narrowly tailored to achieve that interest, using the least restrictive means. The statement that includes both of these elements—a compelling interest and being necessary to achieve it—best reflects this standard.

The other ideas are off because a legitimate, rational-basis interest is not enough under strict scrutiny; recognizing only the least restrictive means is incomplete without asserting a compelling interest; and saying the government must show the best means is not the accepted standard.